• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • News
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Science
  • World
  • Lifestyle
  • Tech
High Court Acquits Directors in $3.8 Million MTN Fraud Case: Ruling Sparks outrage and Fears over Judicial Independence

High Court Acquits Directors in $3.8 Million MTN Fraud Case: Ruling Sparks outrage and Fears over Judicial Independence

May 4, 2025
CPHIA 2026: African Leaders to Convene in Addis Ababa to Advance Health Security and Sovereignty.

CPHIA 2026: African Leaders to Convene in Addis Ababa to Advance Health Security and Sovereignty.

November 22, 2026
Tooro Kingdom rocked as Prime Minister Calvin Rwomire Akiiki resigns, calls for unity amid internal divisions

Tooro Kingdom rocked as Prime Minister Calvin Rwomire Akiiki resigns, calls for unity amid internal divisions

November 22, 2026
Mulago UIAHMS medical graduates urged to uphold professional ethics, compassion in service

Mulago UIAHMS medical graduates urged to uphold professional ethics, compassion in service

November 22, 2026
UPDF FC secured a 2-0 victory over SC Villa

UPDF FC secured a 2-0 victory over SC Villa

November 22, 2026
Uganda AIDS Commission boss Nelson Musoba dies

Uganda AIDS Commission boss Nelson Musoba dies

November 22, 2026
Trade Unions Warn of Deepening Workers’ Poverty, Demand Minimum Wage and Better Protection

Trade Unions Warn of Deepening Workers’ Poverty, Demand Minimum Wage and Better Protection

November 21, 2026
Christmas Joy and Excitement as Two Masaka Women Win First Toyota Probox and TukTuk in MTN Kamata X-mas Promotion

Christmas Joy and Excitement as Two Masaka Women Win First Toyota Probox and TukTuk in MTN Kamata X-mas Promotion

November 21, 2026
Court summons Deputy Mufti to Appear in Shs1.2bn Gold Deal Case

High Court Nullifies Ntenjeru South MP Election, Orders Fresh Poll

November 20, 2026
Court Denies Susan Kushaba Bail Over Alleged TikTok Publications Against Ministers

Court Denies Susan Kushaba Bail Over Alleged TikTok Publications Against Ministers

November 20, 2026
PPS Kibenge assumes office, VP Alupo wishes him a fruitful tour of duty

PPS Kibenge assumes office, VP Alupo wishes him a fruitful tour of duty

November 20, 2026
West Nile Leaders Demand Disclosure of Mineral Exploration Findings

West Nile Leaders Demand Disclosure of Mineral Exploration Findings

November 20, 2026
Uganda moves to secure global buyers for Pearl Sweet as oil exports draw closer

Uganda moves to secure global buyers for Pearl Sweet as oil exports draw closer

November 20, 2026
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact
Sunday, November 22, 2026
  • Login
Ugnews Line
  • Home
  • News
    • Sports
    • Crime
    • Business
    • Politics
    • Blogs
  • Tech
  • Agriculture
  • Opinion
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
Ugnews Line
No Result
View All Result
Home Court

High Court Acquits Directors in $3.8 Million MTN Fraud Case: Ruling Sparks outrage and Fears over Judicial Independence

by Ugnewsline Reporter
May 4, 2025
in Court
Reading Time: 3 mins read
A A
0
23
SHARES
126
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterLinkedinWhatsAppEmail

KAMPALA– In a ruling that has sent shockwaves through Uganda’s corporate and legal circles, the High Court’s Anti-Corruption Division has acquitted two directors of ThreeWays Shipping Company who were accused of masterminding a $3.8 million fraud against MTN Uganda.

The directors, Mr. Bihamaiso and Mr. Baitwa, faced charges of theft and conspiracy to defraud following the submission of 125 fake invoices between 2009 and 2012. Prosecutors argued that the fraudulent invoices resulted in substantial payments made by MTN Uganda to the ThreeWays account, which was controlled exclusively by the two men.

The case, which has dragged on since 2016, involved a total of six suspects, including insiders from both MTN Uganda and ThreeWays Shipping. However, only the two directors remained on trial by 2024, after plea bargains, death, and dismissals reduced the list of accused.

The Court’s Decision

On April 30, 2025, Hon. Justice Lawrence Gidudu acquitted the accused of all charges, ruling that the prosecution had failed to prove their criminal intent or direct participation in the scheme. The judge acknowledged that fraud had indeed occurred and that the funds were stolen from MTN Uganda’s accounts. However, he held that the fraud was executed by MTN insiders and low-level employees of ThreeWays Shipping, and that there was no evidence to link the directors to the conspiracy.

“The fact that money was deposited in an account they controlled is not, by itself, proof of intent,” the judge ruled.

Legal Community in Disbelief

The judgment has been met with strong criticism from legal experts, corporate leaders, and anti-corruption advocates who say the court ignored compelling circumstantial evidence. They argue that the directors’ exclusive control over the bank account used as the “exit facility” for the stolen funds should have been sufficient to infer knowledge and complicity, especially given the duration and magnitude of the fraud.

“The ruling defies logic,” said one prominent legal analyst. “You cannot accept all the factual and legal underpinnings of a fraud case, and then abruptly absolve those who directly benefited from it—without a coherent explanation.”

Indeed, observers have expressed confusion over the court’s apparent internal contradiction—agreeing with the prosecution’s arguments at every legal turn, only to make a dramatic reversal in the final judgment.

“What could possibly have changed the mind of the judge at the last minute?” one senior lawyer asked. “It is baffling.”

Investor Confidence at Risk

The ruling has broader implications beyond this particular case. Legal and corporate observers warn that the acquittal will severely erode investor confidence in Uganda’s judicial system, especially among multinational corporations.

“Multinational companies operating in Uganda are increasingly vulnerable to internal fraud, and the judiciary is supposed to be their final line of protection,” said a risk analyst working with an international telecom consultancy. “If even a case as clear-cut as this one, backed by forensic bank evidence and witness testimony, cannot lead to conviction, then legal remedies in Uganda are essentially a roll of the dice.”

The prolonged duration of the case—nearly a decade—has also been costly for MTN Uganda in both financial and operational terms. Legal costs, reputational damage, and the loss of over $3 million have strained corporate resources and contributed to growing unease in the investor community.

The Curious Case of Inconsistent Judgments

Legal comparisons have also been drawn between this case and Uganda v. Jeff Lawrence Kiwanuka (2017), where the same presiding judge—Justice Gidudu—lifted the corporate veil to convict a director for corporate fraud under nearly identical circumstances.

“In the Jeff Lawrence case, the veil was lifted to expose the real beneficiaries of stolen funds,” one lawyer noted. “But in this case, despite clear evidence that for three years the accused were withdrawing stolen money from MTN, the judge refused to pierce the veil. Why?”

This inconsistent application of precedent has fueled speculation that rulings in such high-profile economic crimes are now being swayed by “clandestine means” rather than legal merit.

Calls for Appeal

In light of these concerns, there are growing calls for the DPP to appeal the judgment. Legal experts argue that the evidence—particularly the flow of money, control of the account, and circumstantial proof of benefit—justifies further judicial review.

“Justice must not only be done—it must be seen to be done,” said one former appellate judge. “This ruling falls short on both counts.”

MTN Uganda, as the complainant in the case, is legally entitled to petition the DPP for an appeal. It remains to be seen whether the office, now under the supervision of the former defense attorney for several accused, will take up the challenge.

Conclusion

The acquittal of Bihamaiso and Baitwa has not only left legal experts bewildered, but has also raised fundamental questions about the integrity and reliability of Uganda’s justice system—particularly in the eyes of international investors and multinational corporations.

With public trust wavering and legal certainty slipping, this case may yet prove to be a turning point in how Uganda addresses white-collar crime—and whether its judiciary can rise above perception to deliver credible justice.

Tags: CourtFEATUREDfraud against mtnhigh courtoutragerullingSparks
Ugnewsline Reporter

Ugnewsline Reporter

Related Posts

Court summons Deputy Mufti to Appear in Shs1.2bn Gold Deal Case

High Court Nullifies Ntenjeru South MP Election, Orders Fresh Poll

by Ugnewsline Reporter
November 20, 2026
0
62

COURT (UGNEWSLINE) - The High Court in Mukono has nullified the election of Ntenjeru County South Member of Parliament in Kayunga...

Court Denies Susan Kushaba Bail Over Alleged TikTok Publications Against Ministers

Court Denies Susan Kushaba Bail Over Alleged TikTok Publications Against Ministers

by Ugnewsline Reporter
November 20, 2026
0
63

COURT (UGNEWSLINE) - Buganda Road Chief Magistrate’s Court has denied bail to businesswoman Susan Kushaba, who is accused of publishing...

City Dentist Ntwatwa Convicted Over Katanga Land Fraud

City Dentist Ntwatwa Convicted Over Katanga Land Fraud

by Ugnewsline Reporter
November 20, 2026
0
61

COURT (UGNEWSLINE) - Kampala dentist, Dr Lule Ntwatwa Ssekiziyivu has been convicted over fraud in regard to forgery of documents on...

Kasese PDM scandal: Four arraigned over alleged Shs136m fraud as fifth suspect goes into hiding

Kasese PDM scandal: Four arraigned over alleged Shs136m fraud as fifth suspect goes into hiding

by Ugnewsline Reporter
November 20, 2026
0
61

KASESE District (UGNEWSLINE)- Four people have appeared before the Anti-Corruption Court over the alleged diversion of Shs136 million in Parish...

  • Makerere University’s CEDAT Trains 250 Construction Site Workers

    Makerere University’s CEDAT Trains 250 Construction Site Workers

    27 shares
    Share 11 Tweet 7
  • Makerere’s CHUSS Pledges to Strengthen Collaboration with JICA Program for Japanese Studies

    26 shares
    Share 10 Tweet 7
  • Gov’t, UWASNET Unveil first-ever WASH Impact and Influence Awards’ categories

    37 shares
    Share 15 Tweet 9
  • The search for Miss and Mr University Uganda is Back

    70 shares
    Share 28 Tweet 18
  • The third edition of Business Languages Festival 2025 launched

    30 shares
    Share 12 Tweet 8
CPHIA 2026: African Leaders to Convene in Addis Ababa to Advance Health Security and Sovereignty.

CPHIA 2026: African Leaders to Convene in Addis Ababa to Advance Health Security and Sovereignty.

November 22, 2026
Tooro Kingdom rocked as Prime Minister Calvin Rwomire Akiiki resigns, calls for unity amid internal divisions

Tooro Kingdom rocked as Prime Minister Calvin Rwomire Akiiki resigns, calls for unity amid internal divisions

November 22, 2026
Mulago UIAHMS medical graduates urged to uphold professional ethics, compassion in service

Mulago UIAHMS medical graduates urged to uphold professional ethics, compassion in service

November 22, 2026
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Ugandan Veterinary Professionals Petition Government Over “Punitive” Licensing Fee Hike

Ugandan Veterinary Professionals Petition Government Over “Punitive” Licensing Fee Hike

April 30, 2026
Over 500 Students Gather at Gayaza High for 11th Annual School Farm Camp

Over 500 Students Gather at Gayaza High for 11th Annual School Farm Camp

August 23, 2025
Court Declares Mandatory Police Enrollment into Exodus SACCO Unconstitutional

Court Declares Mandatory Police Enrollment into Exodus SACCO Unconstitutional

July 15, 2026
UCE RESULTS: Fort Portal secondary school shines again

UCE RESULTS: Fort Portal secondary school shines again

February 11, 2025
Busoga’s Coffee Farmers Told to Register or Risk Losing Market Share

Busoga’s Coffee Farmers Told to Register or Risk Losing Market Share

1
Members of parliament propose a motion for gov’t to establish waste management fund

Members of parliament propose a motion for gov’t to establish waste management fund

1
Moneylenders guide public on how to steer clear of illegal operators

Moneylenders guide public on how to steer clear of illegal operators

1
Yara, Ministry of Agriculture partners to Strengthen Agricultural Standards

Yara, Ministry of Agriculture partners to Strengthen Agricultural Standards

1
CPHIA 2026: African Leaders to Convene in Addis Ababa to Advance Health Security and Sovereignty.

CPHIA 2026: African Leaders to Convene in Addis Ababa to Advance Health Security and Sovereignty.

November 22, 2026
Tooro Kingdom rocked as Prime Minister Calvin Rwomire Akiiki resigns, calls for unity amid internal divisions

Tooro Kingdom rocked as Prime Minister Calvin Rwomire Akiiki resigns, calls for unity amid internal divisions

November 22, 2026
Mulago UIAHMS medical graduates urged to uphold professional ethics, compassion in service

Mulago UIAHMS medical graduates urged to uphold professional ethics, compassion in service

November 22, 2026
UPDF FC secured a 2-0 victory over SC Villa

UPDF FC secured a 2-0 victory over SC Villa

November 22, 2026
Ugnews Line

Copyright © 2024 Ugnewsline.

Navigate Site

  • Home
  • News
  • Tech
  • Agriculture
  • Opinion
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle

Follow Us

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • Sports
    • Crime
    • Business
    • Politics
    • Blogs
  • Tech
  • Agriculture
  • Opinion
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle

Copyright © 2024 Ugnewsline.

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.